IMPERFECTART

Plato’s metaphysics and his Doctrine of Forms describes a general division of our universe into forms and particulars. Forms are instantiated by contingent particulars. That is, particulars are produced by imperfect participation in a form.

His argument is that if an imperfect representation of a thing exists, then there also exists a form to which the thing is relatively imperfect. For example, we may only be able to reproduce imperfect squares, but these representations are based on the perfect form “Square”, a definition of a two-dimensional shape with four equal sides and four right angles.

In later writings (namely Phaedo and The Republic), Plato expands the metaphysical levels at both ends. The mysterious qualities of souls – they are formlike in their perfection, but seem to be instances of something since we each have one – places them somewhere above forms. The more interesting expansion occurs downward (in Plato’s opinion, at least) regarding art. For Plato, since art is a representation of our world – a world composed of particulars – that it somehow ranks below particulars.

Is art really just a duplicate of a flawed universe? Isn’t what makes art beautiful its ability to represent the forms, to be even more real than reality?

  1. I don’t think that art’s beauty comes from its ability to more closely depict the “form” that Plato envisioned. I agree with him that art is a step away from the “perfect form.” Instead of getting us closer to the “real world” (the one outside cave), art provides us with an escape from reality. Why we need that escape is an entirely different topic.

    Matt Davis

    Feb 6, 05:13 PM #

  2. I think art is a personal reception of your own side of perfection. Rather than see it in forms, its can be taken in a general form, than depicted to the own persons sense of perfection, in gathering the sights that they may deem perfect. Therefore, art is taken into that/

    Sheoud

    Mar 8, 09:13 PM #

  3. Maybe art was all this things in the 19th century and before… Not now. Today, art and beauty (and not only beauty) are not necessarly together, and its frontiers have expanded a lot. Left the object of art, and now every art matter is a process. I particulally like it…

    Eduardo

    Nov 25, 12:23 PM #

Add a Comment

Phrase modifiers:

_emphasis_
*strong*
__italic__
**bold**
??citation??
-deleted text-
@code@

Block modifiers:

bq. Blockquote
p. Paragraph

Links:

"linktext":http://example.com


Show Articles By:

You can show articles by time or category.

  • 260.

    Prodigious Savants and their Abilities

    Savant syndrome, a condition occurring most often in autistic patients, is a rare disorder where mentally retarded individuals have incredible abilities in isolated fields like memory, mathematics,...

    Read More

  • 260.

    Why Medicine Again?

    Medicine isn’t what it used to be. I’ve talked to alot of physicians, researchers and residents recently and I’m not encouraged by what I’ve heard. What seems to motivate many...

    Read More

  • 260.

    What of the Soul?

    I received a question recently that asked what I thought about the existence of a soul given the relative secularity of most of the content on this site. Soul, Mind, whatever you call it refers...

    Read More

  • 260.

    Turtles All the Way Up

    That pervasive question, “what are we doing here”, or more accurately, “what’s the fucking point” continues to steal away my attention (and sanity). Looking up is one impetus, but more...

    Read More

  • 260.

    Frozen Worlds: a Time Puzzle

    I got a bit giddy when we got to the “Space and Time” portion of my Metaphysics class. Most of my semester was spent deciphering bizarre accounts of matter (where two theories’ definitions...

    Read More

  • 260.

    Ineffable Understanding

    Near-death experiences, hallucinogenic trips, meditation, you’ve probably read about (or felt firsthand) the odd nature of these “out of body” experiences. A philosophically interesting...

    Read More

  • 260.

    The Neurobiology of Freedom

    So, consciousness is accompanied by an experience of freedom, which phenomenologically speaking, does not seem illusory. But, what exactly does that mean about consciousness and our brain? There are...

    Read More

  • 260.

    Natural Kinds in Chemistry

    One of my favorite courses so far was last semester’s “Natural Kinds”. Everything from the unique subject matter to the seminar-like structure made the class a blast, up until the...

    Read More